Active or passive: does the doer matter?
The same facts, three sentences. Who ends up looking responsible depends entirely on which one you write.
By Dilnoza Yusufova · Linguist
In short
- The subject position is the spotlight: whatever you put there is what the sentence is about.
- Use the active when the doer is the news; the passive when the thing affected is.
- A passive with no by removes the doer from the sentence — and often from the reader’s mind.
The same event, three sentences
The same event, reported three ways. Press each and see what a reader takes away.
Our engineers deleted the customer database.
A company is writing to its customers after an outage.
The customer database was deleted by our engineers.
The same event, passive, with the doer still named.
The customer database was deleted.
The same event, with no doer at all.
Nothing above is a grammar question. All three sentences are correct English about the same deleted database, and they distribute responsibility quite differently — which is why the choice belongs to the writer and not to a style rule.
Active
The doer is the subject. Short, direct, and somebody is accountable.
The council rejected the plan.
- news headlines
- stories
- accusations
- instructions to a person
Passive
The thing affected is the subject. The doer may follow, or may vanish.
The plan was rejected.
- reports
- procedures
- science
- official letters
A decision table
| Situation | Choose | Because |
|---|---|---|
| the doer is the news | active | A cyclist found the painting. |
| the thing is the news | passive | The painting was found in a loft. |
| nobody knows the doer | passive | there is nothing to put in front |
| the doer is everybody | passive | English is spoken here. |
| keeping one topic across sentences | either, as needed | the subject carries the thread |
| you are responsible and should say so | active | the passive will be noticed |
| a procedure anyone will follow | passive | the samples are weighed first |
- A cyclist found the missing painting.the finder is the story
- The missing painting was found in a loft.the painting is the story
- English is spoken here.the doer is everybody, so naming them is absurd
- The samples are weighed before mixing.a procedure for whoever does it
- Your application was rejected.the sentence every applicant resents
Mistakes to avoid
Wrong: It is believed by many people that the scheme was badly planned by the council. correct: Many people believe the council planned the scheme badly.
Two passives in one sentence, both with their doers named. If the doer is in the sentence anyway, the passive is buying nothing.
Wrong: Your application was unfortunately not able to be accepted. correct: We could not accept your application.
Stacking a passive on a modal on an adverb to avoid saying we. Readers notice, and it reads worse than the refusal itself.
Wrong: The window was broken by me. correct: I broke the window.
A by me phrase almost always signals that the active sentence was the right one.
Wrong: Mistakes were made and lessons have been learned. correct: We got it wrong, and here is what we changed.
Not a grammar error — a credibility one. Both clauses are passive with no doer, and every reader can hear it.
Keep this
- Whatever stands in the subject position is what the sentence is about.
- If the doer is in the sentence anyway, ask whether the passive is earning its place.
- By me is a sign to rewrite.
Questions readers ask
So should I avoid the passive?
No — about a fifth of English clauses in formal writing are passive, and most of them are the right choice. Avoid the specific case where you know the doer, the doer matters, and you are using the construction to keep them out of the sentence.
Do passives really change how readers assign blame?
Measurably. Studies of eyewitness language and of reporting on violence find that readers attribute less responsibility after passive descriptions of the same event. This is not a theory about grammar; it is why newsrooms argue about sentence construction.
What about scientific writing?
Convention is shifting. Older papers used the passive throughout — the solution was heated — while many journals now encourage we heated the solution, on the grounds that experiments are done by people who should say so. Follow the journal, and know that both are defensible.