By, with, like, as
These four are not interchangeable and the difference is not subtle. One names the method, one the tool, one a resemblance, one an actual role.
By Dilnoza Yusufova · Linguist
In short
- by = the method or the doer: by train, by hand, written by Orwell.
- with = the tool or thing used: with a pen, with scissors.
- like = resembling; as = actually being: works like a teacher / works as a teacher.
Four words, four roles
Press each one. One sentence, four completely different claims.
She sent itbypost.
the method
By names how something is done, in the abstract: by hand, by email, by train. No article follows — that is the signature of this use.
The third and fourth states are the pair worth memorising: works like a teacher and works as a teacher differ by one small word and by an entire employment status.
Every use of all four
| Word | Says | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| by | method, no article | by car, by hand, by email, by mistake |
| by | the doer, in a passive | painted by Goya |
| by | a deadline | by Friday |
| with | the instrument | cut it with scissors |
| with | accompaniment | came with her sister |
| with | a feature | a man with a beard |
| like | resembling | he sings like his father |
| as | the real role | he works as a driver |
| as | introducing a clause | do it as I showed you |
- I’ll send it by email.a method, no article
- Open it with this.an instrument
- He eats like a horse.a resemblance, and a compliment to nobody
- She started as an intern.a real role
- The bridge was designed by an Italian.the doer, in a passive
- A woman with a red umbrella.a feature
Which role does the word assign?
Press each sentence. Which role does the small word assign?
Press through the eight and the five roles separate. Notice that by turns up in three of them — method, transport and doer — which is why it is the busiest of the four words, and the one most often used where with belongs.
Mistakes to avoid
Wrong: I wrote it by a pencil. correct: I wrote it with a pencil. / I wrote it by hand.
A pencil is a tool, so with. By hand is the method, and it takes no article — a reliable sign that by is the right word.
Wrong: She works like a nurse at the hospital. correct: She works as a nurse at the hospital.
If nursing is her job, use as. With like, the sentence says she merely resembles one.
Wrong: It was built with the Romans. correct: It was built by the Romans.
In a passive sentence the doer takes by. With would make the Romans your co-builders.
Wrong: I came here by my car. correct: I came here by car. / I came here in my car.
By car is the method and allows no article or possessive. The moment you specify my car, English switches to in.
Keep this
- by + bare noun for a method; with + a thing for a tool.
- by also names the doer in a passive.
- like resembles; as is.
Questions readers ask
Why by car but in my car?
By + transport is a fixed set of phrases describing the mode: by car, by bus, by train, by air, by sea, and they take no determiner. As soon as a particular vehicle is meant, the phrase becomes ordinary and takes a normal preposition of place: in my car, on the 7:40 train.
Is like as a conjunction really wrong?
Like I said is extremely common in speech and informal writing, and formal English prefers as: as I said. Nobody will misunderstand you either way; the distinction is a register marker, not a comprehension problem.
What about as a child?
A third use of as, meaning during the time when I was: as a child, I hated olives. It is not a role at work but a stage of life, and the structure is the same.