How English works

By, with, like, as

These four are not interchangeable and the difference is not subtle. One names the method, one the tool, one a resemblance, one an actual role.

B1–B2 3 min read Updated 19 November 2026

By Dilnoza Yusufova · Linguist

In short

  • by = the method or the doer: by train, by hand, written by Orwell.
  • with = the tool or thing used: with a pen, with scissors.
  • like = resembling; as = actually being: works like a teacher / works as a teacher.

Four words, four roles

Press each one. One sentence, four completely different claims.

She sent itbypost.

the method

By names how something is done, in the abstract: by hand, by email, by train. No article follows — that is the signature of this use.

The third and fourth states are the pair worth memorising: works like a teacher and works as a teacher differ by one small word and by an entire employment status.

Rule By for the method and for the doer. With for the tool. Like for a resemblance. As for the real thing.

Every use of all four

WordSaysExamples
bymethod, no articleby car, by hand, by email, by mistake
bythe doer, in a passivepainted by Goya
bya deadlineby Friday
withthe instrumentcut it with scissors
withaccompanimentcame with her sister
witha featurea man with a beard
likeresemblinghe sings like his father
asthe real rolehe works as a driver
asintroducing a clausedo it as I showed you

Which role does the word assign?

Press each sentence. Which role does the small word assign?

the method the tool a resemblance the real role the doer

Press through the eight and the five roles separate. Notice that by turns up in three of them — method, transport and doer — which is why it is the busiest of the four words, and the one most often used where with belongs.

The no-article clue Every method phrase with by drops the article: by hand, by car, by post, by chance, by accident, by mistake. If a sentence has an article or a possessive in it, by is probably the wrong preposition — with a pen, in my car, on the bus. That one test resolves most of the confusion between by and with.

Mistakes to avoid

Wrong: I wrote it by a pencil. correct: I wrote it with a pencil. / I wrote it by hand.

A pencil is a tool, so with. By hand is the method, and it takes no article — a reliable sign that by is the right word.

Wrong: She works like a nurse at the hospital. correct: She works as a nurse at the hospital.

If nursing is her job, use as. With like, the sentence says she merely resembles one.

Wrong: It was built with the Romans. correct: It was built by the Romans.

In a passive sentence the doer takes by. With would make the Romans your co-builders.

Wrong: I came here by my car. correct: I came here by car. / I came here in my car.

By car is the method and allows no article or possessive. The moment you specify my car, English switches to in.

Keep this

  1. by + bare noun for a method; with + a thing for a tool.
  2. by also names the doer in a passive.
  3. like resembles; as is.

Questions readers ask

Why by car but in my car?

By + transport is a fixed set of phrases describing the mode: by car, by bus, by train, by air, by sea, and they take no determiner. As soon as a particular vehicle is meant, the phrase becomes ordinary and takes a normal preposition of place: in my car, on the 7:40 train.

Is like as a conjunction really wrong?

Like I said is extremely common in speech and informal writing, and formal English prefers as: as I said. Nobody will misunderstand you either way; the distinction is a register marker, not a comprehension problem.

What about as a child?

A third use of as, meaning during the time when I was: as a child, I hated olives. It is not a role at work but a stage of life, and the structure is the same.

Practise this

Next in this series

Dilnoza Yusufova Linguist

Writes the How English works series on LingoChallenge.