Can, could, be able to
Can is a defective verb: it exists in two forms and no more. Everything English cannot say with it, it says with be able to.
By Dilnoza Yusufova · Linguist
In short
- Can has exactly two forms — can and could. No infinitive, no participle, no future.
- Be able to fills the gaps: will be able to, have been able to, to be able to.
- For one successful occasion in the past, was able to or managed to, not could.
Before the rule: make a guess
Which one is English?
A verb with two forms and a long list of gaps
Most English verbs have five forms. Can has two, and that single fact explains every oddity in this article. There is no to can, no canned, no canning — so the moment a sentence needs an infinitive or a participle, another verb has to do the work.
Press each tense and watch can hand over the work
Shecandrive.
can
The one place can is comfortable.
Ability across time
can
I can swim.
An ability that holds at the moment of speaking — and, usually, generally.
The whole set in one place
| Meaning | Form | Example |
|---|---|---|
| ability now | can | I can read Greek. |
| ability in the past, generally | could | I could read Greek at school. |
| one success in the past | was/were able to, managed to | I was able to read the inscription. |
| one failure in the past | couldn’t, wasn’t able to | I couldn’t read the inscription. |
| ability in the future | will be able to | I’ll be able to read it with a lens. |
| ability up to now | have been able to | I’ve never been able to read his writing. |
| after another verb | to be able to | I want to be able to read it. |
- I can see the sea from here.ability, right now
- She could play the violin at four.a general ability in the past
- After three attempts he was able to start the engine.one occasion, successful
- I’d love to be able to cook like that.after another verb: be able to
- We haven’t been able to reach her.a perfect, so a participle is needed
Mistakes to avoid
Wrong: I will can help you tomorrow. correct: I’ll be able to help you tomorrow.
Two modals never stand together, and can has no infinitive. This is the single most common mistake with modals.
Wrong: Yesterday the lock was stuck, but I could open it. correct: Yesterday the lock was stuck, but I managed to open it.
One occasion that came off takes was able to or managed to. Could would mean you had the general knack of opening it.
Wrong: He can to drive. correct: He can drive.
Modals take the bare infinitive. The to belongs to be able to, not to can.
Wrong: I couldn’t be able to come. correct: I wasn’t able to come. / I couldn’t come.
One of the two is enough. Stacking them says the same thing twice.
Keep this
- Can exists in two forms only: can, could.
- Where a tense needs an infinitive or a participle, use be able to.
- One past success: was able to or managed to. A past failure: couldn’t is fine.
Questions readers ask
Is be able to just a longer can?
No. In the present it is longer and slightly more formal, so can wins. Everywhere else it is not an alternative but the only option: will be able to, have been able to, to be able to.
Why does couldn’t work for failure but could not for success?
Because a failure is naturally general — nothing happened, so there is no single event to point at. A success is a specific event, and could cannot point at one.
What about could as a polite request?
That is a different could altogether — the hypothetical one, same as in I could help if you asked. It has nothing to do with past ability, which is why Could you pass the salt? is about now.