How English works

Cleft sentences: “It was John who…”

English cannot move words around for emphasis, so it does something stranger: it splits the sentence in half and puts one piece in the spotlight.

C1 4 min read Updated 12 November 2026

By Dilnoza Yusufova · Linguist

In short

  • It was John who called puts John in the spotlight; the rest of the sentence waits behind.
  • What I need is a holiday does the same job with a whole phrase.
  • Both are devices for emphasis, and both are commoner in writing and in careful speech than learners expect.

Before the rule: make a guess

Why would somebody say “It was John who paid” instead of “John paid”?

Two ways to build a spotlight

it-cleft

Spotlights one element — a person, a thing, a time — and pushes the rest behind who or that.

It was the rain that ruined the party.

  • corrections
  • contrasts
  • courtroom English
  • news

what-cleft

Spotlights a whole phrase by naming it first and defining it with be.

What I need is a week off.

  • complaints
  • presentations
  • explaining a problem

Both constructions take a simple sentence and split it in two, so that one part can be announced and the rest can follow as known information. Nothing is added; the weight is moved.

It was in 1979 thatIt was John whoWhat I need isAll I want is

formal, written ordinary speech

Rule It is / it was + the spotlighted element + who or that. Or what + a clause + is + the spotlighted phrase.

Every pattern

FormSpotlight onExample
it was … who/thata personIt was Ana who found it.
it was … thata thingIt was the noise that woke me.
it was … thata time or placeIt was in 1979 that they met.
it wasn’t until … thata delayed momentIt wasn’t until Monday that we heard.
what … isa whole phraseWhat worries me is the cost.
what … do isan actionWhat she did was resign.
all … isa minimumAll I want is an answer.
the thing/reason … isa reasonThe reason I asked is that…
The cleft as an argument Clefts are the grammar of disagreement. It was the rain that ruined the party implies somebody blamed something else. What I actually said was… implies you were misquoted. All I want is an answer implies you have been given everything but. In each case the construction carries an objection that is never stated outright — which is why these sentences feel pointed even when every word in them is neutral.

Mistakes to avoid

Wrong: It was John which called. correct: It was John who called.

A person takes who or that, never which — the ordinary relative-pronoun rule applies inside a cleft too.

Wrong: What I need is to a holiday. correct: What I need is a holiday.

The second half of a what-cleft is a plain noun phrase or a verb phrase. No preposition is needed to attach it.

Wrong: It was because of the rain that we left early because it was wet. correct: It was because of the rain that we left early.

A cleft already carries the emphasis. Explaining it again in the same sentence undoes the effect.

Wrong: What she did was resigned. correct: What she did was resign.

After what … did was, the verb is a bare infinitive. The tense is already carried by did.

Keep this

  1. It is / it was + the spotlight + who or that.
  2. What + clause + is for a whole phrase.
  3. A cleft adds no facts — it redistributes emphasis.

Questions readers ask

Why does English need these?

Because its word order is too rigid to emphasise by moving things. A Russian or Spanish speaker can shift the important word to the front and leave the grammar alone; English cannot, so it builds a second clause instead. Clefts, the passive and there is are all answers to the same constraint.

Are they formal?

The it-cleft leans formal — it is the voice of courtrooms and news reports. The what-cleft is entirely ordinary in speech: what I don’t understand is why nobody called is something anyone might say over dinner.

Is it was me who or it was I who?

It was me who did it in every normal register. It was I follows the older rule about be taking a subject pronoun, and now sounds formal to the point of comedy outside legal writing.

Practise this

Next in this series

Dilnoza Yusufova Linguist

Writes the How English works series on LingoChallenge.