Cleft sentences: “It was John who…”
English cannot move words around for emphasis, so it does something stranger: it splits the sentence in half and puts one piece in the spotlight.
By Dilnoza Yusufova · Linguist
In short
- It was John who called puts John in the spotlight; the rest of the sentence waits behind.
- What I need is a holiday does the same job with a whole phrase.
- Both are devices for emphasis, and both are commoner in writing and in careful speech than learners expect.
Before the rule: make a guess
Why would somebody say “It was John who paid” instead of “John paid”?
Two ways to build a spotlight
it-cleft
Spotlights one element — a person, a thing, a time — and pushes the rest behind who or that.
It was the rain that ruined the party.
- corrections
- contrasts
- courtroom English
- news
what-cleft
Spotlights a whole phrase by naming it first and defining it with be.
What I need is a week off.
- complaints
- presentations
- explaining a problem
Both constructions take a simple sentence and split it in two, so that one part can be announced and the rest can follow as known information. Nothing is added; the weight is moved.
formal, written ordinary speech
Every pattern
| Form | Spotlight on | Example |
|---|---|---|
| it was … who/that | a person | It was Ana who found it. |
| it was … that | a thing | It was the noise that woke me. |
| it was … that | a time or place | It was in 1979 that they met. |
| it wasn’t until … that | a delayed moment | It wasn’t until Monday that we heard. |
| what … is | a whole phrase | What worries me is the cost. |
| what … do is | an action | What she did was resign. |
| all … is | a minimum | All I want is an answer. |
| the thing/reason … is | a reason | The reason I asked is that… |
- It was the dog that ate it.not the child, as you assumed
- It wasn’t until I got home that I noticed.a delayed realisation
- What I can’t stand is the waiting.a complaint, in ordinary speech
- What he did was sell the house.bare infinitive after was
- All I asked for was a receipt.a minimum, and a reproach
Mistakes to avoid
Wrong: It was John which called. correct: It was John who called.
A person takes who or that, never which — the ordinary relative-pronoun rule applies inside a cleft too.
Wrong: What I need is to a holiday. correct: What I need is a holiday.
The second half of a what-cleft is a plain noun phrase or a verb phrase. No preposition is needed to attach it.
Wrong: It was because of the rain that we left early because it was wet. correct: It was because of the rain that we left early.
A cleft already carries the emphasis. Explaining it again in the same sentence undoes the effect.
Wrong: What she did was resigned. correct: What she did was resign.
After what … did was, the verb is a bare infinitive. The tense is already carried by did.
Keep this
- It is / it was + the spotlight + who or that.
- What + clause + is for a whole phrase.
- A cleft adds no facts — it redistributes emphasis.
Questions readers ask
Why does English need these?
Because its word order is too rigid to emphasise by moving things. A Russian or Spanish speaker can shift the important word to the front and leave the grammar alone; English cannot, so it builds a second clause instead. Clefts, the passive and there is are all answers to the same constraint.
Are they formal?
The it-cleft leans formal — it is the voice of courtrooms and news reports. The what-cleft is entirely ordinary in speech: what I don’t understand is why nobody called is something anyone might say over dinner.
Is it was me who or it was I who?
It was me who did it in every normal register. It was I follows the older rule about be taking a subject pronoun, and now sounds formal to the point of comedy outside legal writing.