Modals of deduction: must be, can’t be, might be
When English reasons out loud, it does not say probably. It changes the verb — and the verb tells you how much evidence the speaker has.
By Dilnoza Yusufova · Linguist
In short
- This must is not obligation: it means this is the only explanation left.
- Its negative is can’t be, never mustn’t be.
- For the past, add have: must have been, can’t have been, might have been.
Reasoning, one clue at a time
Press the clues you have noticed. The verdict rewrites itself.
She might be at home.
No evidence either way. Might be is the honest verb for that.
Nothing in the sentence changed except the modal verb, and that one word reported how much evidence stood behind the conclusion. This is what English does instead of probably, perhaps and definitely.
The same word, two different jobs
- You must be joking.a conclusion: nothing else explains what you said
- You must call her today.an obligation: a completely different must
- He can’t be forty.ruled out — he does not look it
- He mustn’t be late.forbidden — and nothing to do with deduction
- The parcel should be here by Friday.a prediction from the evidence
The split runs deep enough that the two meanings do not even share a negative. Obligation negates to mustn’t; deduction negates to can’t.
Looking back: add have
For a conclusion about the past, every one of these words keeps its meaning and gains have.
| Form | Evidence | Past form |
|---|---|---|
| must be | the only explanation left | must have been |
| should be | enough to predict it | should have been |
| may / might be | possible, nothing decides | may / might have been |
| could be | one candidate among several | could have been |
| might not be | possibly not | might not have been |
| can’t be | ruled out by the evidence | can’t have been |
- She must have missed the train.the only explanation for her being late
- He can’t have known.the evidence rules it out
- They might have forgotten.possible, nothing decides it
Mistakes to avoid
Wrong: He mustn’t be the owner — he’s far too young. correct: He can’t be the owner — he’s far too young.
Mustn’t forbids. The negative of this must is can’t, and the two meanings of must do not share a negative.
Wrong: She must been tired. correct: She must have been tired.
For a past conclusion the pattern is modal + have + participle. The have is not optional.
Wrong: It must be rain — look at the clouds. correct: It must be raining. / It’s going to rain.
Must be needs a complement that can be true now: an adjective, a noun phrase or -ing.
Wrong: He must to be the manager. correct: He must be the manager.
Bare infinitive after a modal, here as everywhere.
Keep this
- Must be is a conclusion, not a duty.
- The negative is can’t be; mustn’t means something else entirely.
- Past conclusions: must have been, can’t have been, might have been.
Questions readers ask
How do I know which must I am reading?
By what follows. Must be, must have and must know are conclusions; must go, must call, must tell are obligations. In practice the verb after it decides, and a state verb almost always signals deduction.
Is should be really deduction?
Yes, and it is common: The parcel should be there by now is a prediction from evidence, not an instruction to the parcel. The same form does both jobs, and here too the following verb tells you which.
What about surely and obviously?
They can be added, but English prefers to carry the certainty in the verb. He must be joking is stronger and more natural than surely he is joking, and it is the pattern a native speaker reaches for first.