Relative clauses: who, which, that
A relative clause is a whole sentence used as a description. The relative pronoun is the hook that fastens it to the noun.
By Dilnoza Yusufova · Linguist
In short
- who for people, which for things, that for either in a defining clause.
- If the pronoun is the object, you can leave it out: the book (that) I lost.
- whose covers possession for both people and things.
What the hook is holding
Press a highlighted word. The relative pronoun lights up with the noun it reaches back to.
called yesterday has left a message.
Who carries the colour of the woman because it stands for her: she is the one who called. The relative pronoun is the subject of its own clause here, and it cannot be dropped.
The third state is the one worth pausing on. English allows the hook to disappear entirely when it is an object, leaving two clauses simply standing next to each other — the book I lost — and learners reading at speed often cannot see where one clause ends and the other begins.
Every relative word
| Pronoun | Stands for | Example |
|---|---|---|
| who | a person (subject or object) | the man who phoned |
| whom | a person as object — formal | the man whom I met |
| which | a thing | the car which broke down |
| that | a person or a thing, defining only | the car that broke down |
| whose | possession, people or things | the man whose car it is |
| where | a place | the town where I grew up |
| when | a time | the day when we met |
| — (nothing) | an object pronoun, deleted | the book Ø I lost |
- The woman who lives upstairs is Polish.subject: the pronoun must stay
- The parcel which arrived this morning is yours.a thing
- The film we saw last night was dreadful.object: the pronoun has gone
- The man whose dog bit me apologised.possession
- The café where we first met has closed.a place
Mistakes to avoid
Wrong: The man which called is my uncle. correct: The man who called is my uncle.
Which is for things. For people English uses who — or that, in a defining clause.
Wrong: The book that I lost it has turned up. correct: The book that I lost has turned up.
That already stands for the book. Adding it gives the clause two objects — a very common error for speakers of Arabic, Persian and Greek.
Wrong: The woman who she lives next door is a doctor. correct: The woman who lives next door is a doctor.
Same error on the subject side. Who is the subject; she is a second one.
Wrong: The city where I was born in is Lisbon. correct: The city where I was born is Lisbon. / The city which I was born in is Lisbon.
Where already contains the in. Use one or the other, not both.
Keep this
- who for people, which for things, that for both in defining clauses.
- Delete the pronoun only when it is the object.
- Never repeat the noun with a pronoun inside the clause.
Questions readers ask
When can I leave the pronoun out?
When it is the object of the clause: the film (that) we saw, the man (who) I met. When it is the subject, it must stay: the man who called, never the man called. The test is whether another subject follows — if there is one, the pronoun is an object and can go.
That or which?
In a defining clause both are correct in British English; American style guides prefer that. In a non-defining clause — the kind with commas — only which is possible: the car, which was new, broke down. That distinction has its own article.
Is whom finished?
In speech, largely. It survives after prepositions — the person to whom it was addressed — and in formal writing. The man who I met is standard spoken English, and the version with whom can sound stiff outside a legal document.