Wh-questions: where the question word goes
A wh-question is an ordinary question with one extra word in front. The trouble starts when that word is the subject, because then the usual machinery switches off.
By Dilnoza Yusufova · Linguist
In short
- The question word goes first, and the ordinary question is built behind it.
- Subject questions are the exception: Who called? needs no did at all.
- A preposition usually stays at the end: What are you looking at?
Before the rule: make a guess
Somebody rang the bell. You want to ask who it was. Which question?
The exception you can see
Watch what happens when the question word is the subject
Whodidshering?
Normal machinery
Who is what she rang, so the sentence still needs did in front of the subject.
Two of these three are ordinary questions with a word added in front. The middle one is different: who is doing the ringing, so it is already in the subject’s place, and there is nothing for an auxiliary to jump over.
Which questions take “do”
| Question word asks about | Example | Does do appear? |
|---|---|---|
| the object | What did you buy? | yes |
| place | Where does she live? | yes |
| time | When did they leave? | yes |
| reason | Why are you late? | no — be moves itself |
| the subject | Who wrote this? | no — nothing moves |
| the subject | What happened? | no — nothing moves |
The pair that proves it
- Who called you?who is the subject: no did, verb keeps its tense
- Who did you call?who is the object: did comes back
- What happened?subject question
- What did you do?object question
Mistakes to avoid
Wrong: Who did wrote this? correct: Who wrote this?
A subject question needs no auxiliary at all, and the verb keeps its own tense.
Wrong: Where you are from? correct: Where are you from?
The question word goes first, but the auxiliary still has to come before the subject.
Wrong: What means this word? correct: What does this word mean?
What is the object here, so the ordinary machinery applies. The faulty version copies word order from other languages.
Wrong: Why you didn’t call? correct: Why didn’t you call?
The negative auxiliary moves in front of the subject just like the positive one.
Keep this
- Question word first, auxiliary second, subject third.
- If the question word is the subject, nothing moves and do never appears.
- Be moves by itself here too: Why are you late?
Questions readers ask
How do I tell a subject question from the others?
Answer it. If the answer replaces the subject — Sara rang — it is a subject question. If the answer replaces something after the verb — I rang Sara — the ordinary machinery applies.
What about “Who did you see?” and “Who saw you?”
The first asks about the object and keeps did; the second asks about the subject and drops it. The pair is the clearest demonstration of the rule there is.
Is “Whom” still used?
Rarely, and mostly after a preposition: To whom should I send it? In everyday English who covers both jobs.